Friday, 25 November 2016

Homology


السلام عليكم و رحمة الله

Remember that homology means similarity between two different creatures due to common ancestor - anatomically or genetically (or molecular) . Which means that a human and a bacteria should have less in common than between a human and a chimp. The more unsimilar you are the further away the common ancestor between the two is and the more similar you are, the more recent your common ancestor is. Homology is used every time among evolutionist to determine the split between two creatures. This is the standard method used by Charles Darwin himself - which is why he believed that the humans and chimps had common ancestor due to their similarity. How can you falsify such belief? All you have to do is to show high similarity between creatures that look nothing like each other genetically or show less similarity between two creatures that look alike genetically. 

Here is an example to understand. Imagine a cat, bat and a bird. Based on Darwin's own method we just need to look and whoever looks similar had a recent common ancestor. Who is closer to the bird? The cat or the bat? It is obviously the bat. There is no question about it. Therefore the evidence of homology must point to high similarity between bat and bird and less similarity between cat and bird on the genetic level (because we already established that bat is more similar to bird than a cat - so anatomical homology should be in accordance to genetic similarity if homology is true). Yet to our surprise the genetic evidence contradicts the anatomical evidence. The cat is more similar to the bird than the bat. Sean B. Carrol said,

"...consider bats and birds, both of which have adaptations that enable flight. This superficial resemblance might imply that bats are more closely related to birds than they are to cats, which cannot fly. But a closer examination reveals that a bat's wing is far more similar to the forelimbs of cats... than to a bird's wing" [1]

So homology is contradicted and thus unreliable. At least that's what common sense dictates but evolutionist have their way out. This contradiction has it's own name called homoplasy (or convergent evolution - to sound too scientific). This means that similarity between unsimilar creatures is due to pure accident. It just happened to be similar. So homology contradicts homoplasy and homoplasy contradicts homology. Moreover you cannot falsify the data. It's either homology or homoplasy. If similarity can arise by pure chance then how exactly can we trust Darwin's own method? And since similarity and unsimilarity are both evidence for evolution then does homology or homoplasy have any real meaning? Despite the obvious contradiction between homology and homoplasy, they - the evolutionist - still use homology and homoplasy as if they don't contradict each other. Also how can you possibly know if something is homology or homoplasy? You can't. You simply make it up as you go along. If you want the alleged 99% similarity between apes and humans as homology then you say its homology and if you don't want to say that then say it's homoplasy. 

Homology is really the method of forging your own ancestors. It has no real meaning behind it or scientific evidence. It's mere conjecture and imagination. 

What I showed above is contradiction between anatomical and molecular evidence. But there is even a contradiction between molecular evidences.

Michael Lynch notes that a study, led by Wray (and others), showed similarities between genes and came with the date of 1.0 to 1.2 billion for the origin of major animal phyla.[2] But other works showed that the origin of major animal phyla is actually just 800 million years ago.[3] But other molecular evidence shows yet different stories. Lynch again notes that a study led by Ayala (and others) showed that the origin for the major phyla at 600-670 million years.[4] What that means is that even molecular evidence contradicts molecular evidence all the time. It was first assumed that all genes change at a constant rate but soon enough it was discovered that change occurs at an irregular rate: some fast, some slow.[5] An example would be histone protein which hardly changes and thus evolutionist will never use histone proteins[6] because then any creature would be our cousin and had recent common ancestor with us. That is bad because that would contradict the anatomical homology between chimps and humans. So here is evidence of molecular evidence contradicting molecular. Despite this blatant problems and unsolvable problems Lynch says,

"Given the substantial evolutionary time separating the animal phyla, it is not surprising that single-gene analyses yield such discordant results. Under such circumstances, the statistical noise associated with the substitution process leads to a high probability that phylogenetic analyses based on different molecules will yield different topologies. "[7]

Which simply means that whenever evolutionist want a data to suit them, they accept it and whenever they don't like it they refuse it with fairytale stories about quick change or some unknown event that changes everything. Also it means that different genes give different stories. (Topology in this context means trees)

But that's not all. There are genes that can't fit homology at all. Those genes are known as ORFan genes. Those genes are so unique they exhibit no similarity to any existing gene (that's why they are called orfan genes, which is orphan genes). Those ORFan genes are everywhere and evolutionist will not use those to make evolutionary trees since they won't fit the pattern they like. It is said that there 1000 ORFan genes in humans[8]. Get it? 1000 genes is equal to approximately 5-6% of our DNA. So how are we 99% or 98.5% or 97% similar to chimps? It's impossible. So add to the 5-6% the 2% alleged differences, you get 8% difference between humans and chimps - that is 92% similarity. No more 95% or above. No doubt more ORFan genes will be found and the alleged similarity will fade away. But the question is how does ORFan genes come to existence? It couldn't arise by gene duplication.[9] So where do they come from? Though there is no certain answer but some evolutionist claimed that ORFan genes came by a process called de novo. Which simply means once upon a time a junk gene existed[10]. This junk gene which is as good as a garbage bin changed as time went on and miraculously became functional and so unique. Yes garbage changed to purity and cleanliness by chance. This is how bad homology has become. It was believed that ORFan genes is impossible since homology/evolution doesn't predict that[11] but now it's flooding everywhere and anywhere. A false prediction.

Due to these problems you start to understand why ideas like the web of life, bush of life, forest of life etc come to rise. The tree of life as Dawkins once thought was true[12] has died. And the reason why there is even a tree, web or bush of life is because evolutionist assume that alleged similarity means common ancestor. If you stop assuming, you will have no tree, web or forest of life. What you will have is dots across the page, each dot representing sudden appearances of animals.

To summarise homology (also called "molecular evidence") is the method of forging your own ancestors. Remember the saying? The strong, the ones in power, writes history (i.e. lie about the past). It is happening in front of your eyes cloaked in a respected area of research called science. Homology "is still a funny word: in the context of proteins and genes, it makes sense only if we don’t think about it too deeply" and a "useless word"[13]

Here is another example when different body structure give you different stories. For example when Lucy was uncovered, the evolutionist believed that Lucy evolved into a Australopithecus africanus and then into you and me.

Why? Because the head of Lucy appeared more ape-like than africanus[14]. But then a discovery was made in Sterkfontein[15] which is of africanus which shows that its legs was more ape-like than Lucy's![16] So now the legs are giving a different story than the heads. Did Lucy's descendants revert back to apish-ness? If yes then how does that explain the alleged "human-like" head of africanus? 

That is just an example of how different body parts (head and leg in this case) give different stories. Now africanus is thrown away as a side-branch dead end since they don't want it to put doubt on Lucy. Of course all these fake tree drawings are just fancy trees they like. It may well be true that Lucy's descendants reverted (that's if Lucy had human-like legs) since evolution is random. But that's one example.

In fact one author denied Lucy altogether[17]. His claim is obviously rejected but Clarke discovered an Australopithecus which was not knuckle-walking (Lucy was) and he believed that it evolved into humans thus throwing Lucy to an evolutionary dead-end. He said that his discovery "argues against the commonly held view that human... ancestor would have been long-armed and knuckle-walk[ing]..." and that it argued against the fact that humans and chimps are closely related[18]

This all happened in 2002. Who knows what happened next but that Lucy vs africanus is definitely an important example. 

But taking this incident and reflect upon it, does homology really give a consistent story? Does it even give a story in the first place? Can fossil evidence even give a story? No. For example, here we have Lucy in all her glory, how do we know for sure that she evolved into humans? We don't know. What if she became  a chimpanzee? What if she and her family went actually extinct without evolving like africanus, robustus etc? How do we know for sure what really happened? What if Lucy isn't Lucy[19]? What if Lucy became Homo naledi?[20] We will never know. Homology fails to help and homoplasy refutes homology.

Fairytales after fairytales.

Note: I wrote this for my friend. I prefer to keep my articles strictly about history.

و الله اعلم


References and notes


[1] Neil A. Campbell and Jane B. Reece, 8th edition, Biology, page 541 (emphasis is mine). It's a biology textbook.

[2] Michael Lynch, The Age and Relationships of the Major Animal Phyla, Evolution, Vol 53, No. 2 (Apr., 1999) pp. 319-325 (p. 319).  For free access see http://www.indiana.edu/~lynchlab/PDF/Lynch90.pdf


[3] Douglas H. Erwin et al, The Cambrian Conundrum: Early Divergence and Later Ecological success in the early history of animals, Science, 25 November 2011, Vol.334(6059), pp. 1091-7. See http://science.sciencemag.org/content/334/6059/1091.full


[4]  Michael Lynch, The Age and Relationships of the Major Animal Phyla, Evolution, Vol 53, No. 2 (Apr., 1999) pp. 319-325 (p. 320).For free access see http://www.indiana.edu/~lynchlab/PDF/Lynch90.pdf


[5] Simon Y. W. Ho and Sebastian Duchene, Molecular-clock methods for estimating evolutionary rate and timescales, Molecular Ecology (2014) 23, 5947-5965 (p. 5947). See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25290107


[6] Ernst Mayr, 2002, What Evolution Is; Ibid, page 5951

[7]  Michael Lynch, The Age and Relationships of the Major Animal Phyla, Evolution, Vol 53, No. 2 (Apr., 1999) pp. 319-325 (p. 323). For free access see http://www.indiana.edu/~lynchlab/PDF/Lynch90.pdf




[9]  Ruiz-Orera J et al. (2015) Origins of De Novo Genes in Human and Chimpanzee. PLoS Genet 11(12).
Gene duplication is a gene that is duplicated. So let's say for example you have gene which has the letters AAAA and you duplicate that to get another AAAA. So now you have two genes with the exact code. Then vision that the first gene changes and becomes AAAB whilst the other gene changes and becomes AAAG. There is 75% similarity between these two gene. That is exactly what gene duplication is, just longer codes.

[10] Christian Schlotterer, Genes from scratch - the fate of de novo genes, Trends in Genetics, Volume 31, Issue 4, 215-219.
For free access see http://www.cell.com/trends/genetics/pdf/S0168-9525(15)00034-7.pdf; Aoife McLysaght and Laurence D. Hurst,Open questions in the study of de novo genes: what, how and why, Nature Reviews Genetics 17, 567-578 (2016). See http://www.nature.com/nrg/journal/v17/n9/abs/nrg.2016.78.html


[11] Christian Schlotterer, Genes from scratch - the fate of de novo genes, Trends in Genetics, Volume 31, Issue 4, 215-219. For free access see http://www.cell.com/trends/genetics/pdf/S0168-9525(15)00034-7.pdf

[12] Richard Dawkins, 2009, The Greatest Show on Earth, Bantam Press chapter 10

[13]  Ford Doolittle, The nature of the universal ancestor and the evolution of the proteome, Current Opinion in Structural Biology, Volume 10, Issue 3, pages 355-358. See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10851188


[14] Mark Collard and Leslie Aiello, "From forelimbs to two legs" Nature 404 (March 23, 2000): 339-340

[15] Clarke and Phillip Tobias, "Sterkfontein member 2 foot bones of the oldest South African hominid" Science 269 (5223):521-524 

[16] Lee Berger and Phillip Tobias, "A chimpanzee-like tibia from Sterkfontein, South Africa and its implications for the interpretation of bipedalism in Australopithecus africanus" Journal of Human Evolution, April 1996, Vol 30 (4):343-348

[17] Clarke, "Newly revealed information on the Sterkfontein Member 2 Australopithecus skeleton", South African Journal of Science 98, November/December 2002. 523-526

[18] Ibid, 526

[19] Because Lucy was discovered scattered across a hillside. The bones were not found together, therefore some came up with the idea of "family" rather than one person called Lucy. The reason why it was accepted as being one is because no two of the same bones were found therefore, most likely, the bones relate to one person but recently one bone of Lucy's backbone belongs to a baboon (https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn27325-baboon-bone-found-in-famous-lucy-skeleton/). So is Lucy a mixture of God knows what? Lucy lived with baboons? Why did not the baboons evolve since they all lived in the alleged harsh climate?


[20] Homo naledi never became a human since it coexisted with humans, its alleged age is 912 ka years old. See Mana Dembo et al, "The evolutionary relationships and age of Homo naledi: An assessment using dated Bayesian phylogenetic methods" Journal of Human Evolution 97 (2016) 17-26

Sunday, 13 November 2016

Women's evolution

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله

Some women are not happy with the standard story of evolution. Why you ask? Because the male is the hero all the time. Think about it. When was the last time you heard of the female ape-human creature saving her husband and child? When was the last time you heard the female hunting in the open Savannah of the desert of Africa for food? It's always a he always a male. The female is the lonely ape-like creature on the trees. She's only mentioned at breast feeding the baby and mating with the heroic ape-human creature. And Elaine Morgan (1920-2013) tries to break this male-centered view in the standard evolutionary theory stories on human evolution.
Elaine Morgan

She has wrote a whole book entitled The Descent of Woman (get it? Darwin wrote The Descent of Man). The whole book is one long speculative fairy-tale story about how ape-human women evolved. She starts with how men think of women; as a man gone wonky,

"Throughout most of the literature dealing with the differences between the sexes there runs a subtle underlying assumption that woman is a man gone wonky; that woman is a distorted version of the original blueprint; that they are the norm, and we are the deviation"[1]

She thought that "It might have been expected that when Darwin came along and wrote an entirely different account of The Descent of Man [sic], this assumption [i.e. that women are men gone wonky] would have been eradicated... But it didn't"[2]

Even though she said that at least Darwin's idea made woman and man "contemporaneous" rather than woman created a while after from man, she did forget to mention more than just that from Darwin's Descent.

In the Descent[3] Darwin argues that women are inferior to men. But why are men superior to women? Darwin explains,

"It is generally admitted that with women the power of intuition, of rapid perception, and perhaps of imitation, are more strongly marked than in man; but some, at least, of these faculties are characteristic of the lower races, and therefore of a past and lower state of civilisation."

So because women have the power of intuition, rapid perception and imitation that makes the women inferior.

Let's define the words.

Intuition: knowledge or perception not gained by reasoning and intelligence[4]

Perception: (1) the act or the effect of perceiving (2) insight or intuition gained by perceiving (3) the ability or capacity to perceive (4) the process by which an organism detects and interprets information from the external world by means of the sensory receptor

Imitation[5]: (2) to pretend to be or to impersonate [something]

What Darwin is saying is that the savages (the blacks, like the Fuegians, Australians etc and religious people) are very intuitive (i.e. gaining knowledge without reasoning or intelligence) and that the womenfolk are similar to the savages in this respect. He's also saying that the savages are good at perceiving (isn't that good?) and women are good at perceiving therefore women are inferior to men and finally savages don't make anything new (they do and Darwin himself admits to that but he's talking in the general sense) rather they need to be taught by/copy the superior beings (i.e. the male whites) and somehow women also only imitate therefore they are inferior.

Darwin carries on throwing fanciful statistics around too,

"The chief distinction in the intellectual powers of the two sexes is shewn by man attaining to a higher eminence, in whatever he takes up, than women can attain - whether requiring deep thought, reason, or imagination, or merely the use of the senses and hands.If two list were made of the most eminent men and women in poetry, painting, sculpture, music,-comprising composition and performance, history, science and philosophy, with half-a-dozen names under each subject, the two lists would not bear comparison. We may also infer, from the law of the deviation of averages, so well illustrated by Mr Galton,[6] in his work on 'Hereditary Genius,' that if men are capable of decided eminence over women in many subjects, the average standard of mental power in man must be above that of women"(585 - italics are mine)

Most of that requires no explanation but the last sentence does. What Darwin means by "average standard of mental power in man must be above that of women" is that if statistics were shown that men are always smarter, then women are inferior (as Darwin believed). But the opposite is true, if statistics show that women are smarter then, men are inferior. Which also means that there is such a thing as "inferior" and "superior" not just among races of man (which Darwin also believed in) but also between the genders!

(Hold on a minute... If women imitate... Where did they learn kindness and sweetness? Men allegedly were hunting in the desert with brutal power in order to eat and be biped over millions of years. Did the man have kindness too over the kids? If yes what did the women do then? Something sounds fishy).

Then he beautifully summarizes what he means (should be written in gold! Joking)

"Thus man has ultimately become superior to woman" (586  - bold are mine - I felt greatness after reading that - joking again).

He even says that it is fortunate or else man and women would've been the same!

"It is, indeed, fortunate that the law of equal transmission of characters to both sexes has commonly prevailed throughout the whole class of mammals; otherwise it is probable that man would have become as superior in mental endowment to women, as the peacock is in ornamental plumage to the peahen" (586)

I am not sure whether this is a sign of happiness that man is superior to woman but it does seem that Darwin did feel fortunate/happy that man is superior.

In another passage Darwin says,

"Man is more powerful in body and mind than woman..." (620)

But did you know that Darwin used to call his own wife mammy?[7] So much for inferiority.

But that's not all. Darwinist started (before Darwin even published Descent) to try to prove that women are inferior to men not just by the fact that men occupy the seat of knowledge but also by the fact that women generally have smaller heads to men. That has a meaning for the Darwinist. The idea that women have smaller heads than men meant only one thing: inferiority. Carl Vogt, an admirer of Darwin (and whom Darwin mentions in the Descent) said,

"By its rounded apex and less developed posterior lobe the Negro brain resembles that of our children, by the protuberance of the parietal lobe, that of our women... The grown-up Negro partakes, as regards his intellectual  faculties, of the nature of the child, the female, and the senile white..."[8]

And Paul Broca (whom also Darwin mentions) claimed that women's brains are inferior to men.[9]

This is of course where Darwin got his ideas from. He published Origin of Species and people like Vogt and Broca took their cue and formed their racist views, Darwin took their views and incorporated it into Descent.

But one more thing Darwin also claims that women are maybe "missing links" between a child and men. He said,

"The female... in the formation of her skull, is said to be intermediate between the child and man" (579)

And he references Vogt and Ecker on page 603.

Summary

I don't think this requires summary but according to Darwin your mum, sister, wife and all female relatives of yours are proven to be inferior to you (if you're a male).

There is a new book that just came out by Fatima Barkatulla called Khadijah: Mother of History's Greatest Nation. An excellent book on how superior women are. (it's really for children)


References

1. Elaine Morgan, 1985, The Descent of Woman, Souvenir Press, page 7

2. Ibid, page 7

3. Charles Darwin, Darwin: The Descent of Man, Wordsworth Classics of World Literature
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Descent-Man-Classics-World-Literature/dp/1840226986/ref=pd_sim_14_2?ie=UTF8&psc=1&refRID=76G4FD9HY64DGT4VQHEQ

4. I am using The New Collins Concise English dictionary for all the definitions. First published in 1979 but the same definition is on Oxford dictionary https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/intuition

5. I am defining 'imitate' rather than imitation.

6. Francis Galton is the cousin of Darwin.

7. The Correspondence of Charles Darwin, volume 4, Cambridge University Press, pages 146-147

8. Carl Vogt, 1864, Lectures on Man: His place in nature and in the history of the Earth, page 192
    You can access that book for free on https://archive.org/details/lecturesonmanhis00vogtuoft
    It's also in Stephen Jay Gould, 2007, The Richness of life, Vintage, page 515

9. Stephen Jay Gould, 2007, The Richness of life, Vintage, page 515

Wednesday, 9 November 2016

Taught by a Blackmoore

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله


Robert Erasmus Darwin
Like all fathers they want their son(s) to gain a good education, a decent job and a happy life. So was the father of Charles Darwin. Robert Erasmus Darwin[1] (the father of Charles Darwin - the picture on the right) told his son, with definite pressure, to go to Edinburgh University (in Scotland) to learn all the things a doctor requires. That included dissecting human and nonhuman bodies. This involved seeing chopped up flesh, real organs, real blood - raw and uncensored.

But poor Darwin simply couldn't take it. He could not take the sight of blood. So he decided to make his way in the University by not concentrating, not focusing, walking around the grand fields of Edinburgh, wishing for holidays and just having a chill.

One of the things Darwin did to chill was to learn how to stuff birds.[2] What is surprising is that the man who taught Darwin how to do this was a black man. His name was John Edmonstone.[3] John asked for one guinea per hour for two months[4] which was cheap. Darwin enjoyed the time he spent with John and learn a lot from him. John was described by Darwin as an "intelligent" and "pleasant" man.[5] Despite the fact that Darwin was taught by a "negro" in late 1820's (way before he was a evolutionist) he, later on in his life, after converting to evolutionism (or transmutationism as Darwin first called it), claimed that savages (all black people) are inferior in knowledge, ape-like creatures (at least some were) and nowhere near the standard and intelligence of the white. This is how Charles Darwin repaid John Edmonstone.


Reference

1. I added the word "Erasmus" since Erasmus was the father of Robert. The father of any son/daughter should have their name in the middle name of their son/daughter.

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpsQjDkNpMo This is a video about what stuffing is if you didn't know.

3. Even though there is doubt if he really was John Edmonstone. R. B. Freeman explains why there is a doubt and concludes, "A tentative conclusion, with unresolved problems, is that Darwin's negro bird-stuffer was John Edmonstone, originally a slave of Charles Edmonstone of Warrows Place, Mibiri Creek, Demerara River, British Guiana. He came to Scotland, with his master, in 1817, first for a brief period in Glasgow and then, at least in 1823, moved to Edinburgh where he still was in 1833". Quoted in R. B. Freeman, Darwin's Negro Bird-Stuffer, Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London, Vol. 33. No. 1 (Aug., 1978), pages 83-86.

4. Adrian Desmond & James Moore, 1992, Darwin, Penguin, page 28.

5. Janet Browne, 1995, Charles Darwin: Voyaging, Pimlico, page 66

Thursday, 27 October 2016

To marry or not to marry this is the question

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله


"...better than a dog anyhow..."
- Charles Darwin


Emma Wedgwood after her 10th child
Charles Darwin is best remembered as the author of the Origin of Species. Not many look at his life as a man, who lived his life and had his own ups and downs. One of the biggest ups and downs of his life was his severe illness that plagued him after he returned from the voyage that he embarked on for five years. One big decision Darwin had to make, on his return was whether..."to marry or not to marry, this is the question".  Whether Darwin somehow intended for his notes about the pros and cons of this question to be preserved for future generations to see or not is not clear but it gives a great insight into Darwin's thought process.

One of the main reasons he stated for marriage was that having a wife is "...better than a dog anyhow..." I guess Darwin refuted the saying that a dog is man's best friend. I think better than a dog was a compliment for women by Darwin but who knows? I'll let the women of our time be the judge of what was in Darwin's brain when he jotted those words. His pros and cons really do summarize almost everything that a man thinks even today before he marries (apart from the dog of course - only some think that way). Read it for yourself and you will be a professor of the mind of men - without question.

His handwriting of pros and cons of marriage is definitely difficult to read (that was his handwriting after all) but here is what the paper says, 

Marry

Children - (if it please God) - Constant companion, (& friend in old age) who will feel interested in one, - object to be beloved and played with. - -better than a dog anyhow. - Home, & someone to take care of house - charms of music & female chit-chat. - These things good for one's health. - Forced to visit & receive relations but terrible loss of time.

W My God, it is intolerable to think of spending ones whole life, like a neuter bee, working, working, & nothing after all. - No, no won't do. - Imagine living all one's day solitarily in smoky dirty London House. - Only picture yourself a nice soft wife on a sofa with good fire, & books & music perhaps - Compare this vision with the dingy reality of Grt. Marlbro' St. 

Marry - Marry - Marry Q.E.D

Not Marry

No children, (no second life), no one to care one in old age. - what is the use of working 'in' without sympathy from near & dear friends to the old, except relatives

Freedom to go where one liked - choice of Society & little of it. - Conversation of clever men at clubs - Not forced to visit relatives, & bend in every trifle. - to have the expense & anxiety of children - perhaps quarreling  - Loss of time. - cannot read in the Evenings - fatness and idleness - Anxiety and responsibility - less money for books &c - if many children forced to gain one's bread. - (But then it is very hard for ones health to work too much)



His pros and cons why to marry and not to marry

He wrote that in 1838 and got married in 1839.

I would love to see Nouman Ali Khan's interpretation on Darwin's thinking of marriage & the similarity of Darwin's views from an Islamic perspective. (Please share it to Nouman Khan)

Picture and transcription in the paper is taken from http://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?viewtype=side&itemID=CUL-DAR210.8.2&pageseq=1

Saturday, 8 October 2016

Darwin and the Niqab

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله

It might strike you as odd when you know that Darwin and the Niqab had some connection but yes they do. It struck me as odd too.


When Charles Darwin wrote his Descent of Man[1] in chapter 3, he spoke about how beliefs are created by the community for the good in the long term but sometimes it might  "err" due to people's "ignorance and weak powers of reasoning" (meaning not well evolved people, like you and me - the savages). The question is how? What proof? He says,


"The judgement of the community will generally be guided by some rude experience of what is best in the long-run for all the members' but this judgement will not rarely err from ignorance and from weak powers of reasoning. Hence the strangest customs and superstitions, in complete opposition to the true welfare and happiness of mankind, have become all-powerful throughout the world. We see this... in the shame of a Mahometan woman who exposes her face..." (75-76)


It should be clear that Mahometan means Muhammad صلى الله على و سلم. Even Wikipedia agrees by saying,


"Mohammedan (also spelled Muhammadan, Mahommedan, Mahomedan or Mahometan) is a term for a follower of the Islamic prophet Muhammad . It is used as both a noun and an adjective, meaning belonging or relating to, either Muhammad or the religion, doctrines, institutions and practices that he established"[2]


There is even a map showing the countries where "Mohammedan['s]" live throughout the world in 1883.


So according to Darwin, the Niqab (or even Burqa, since they both cover the face but most likely Niqab) is "in complete opposition" to "welfare and happiness of mankind". How does a piece of cloth make the entire mankind happy or not? He is also ridiculing the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad صلى الله على و سلم because it was he who taught us about the covering of the hair and if you wish (though some say it's an obligation) to cover your face. The Prophet صلى الله على و سلم made "strange customs and superstitious" according to Darwin even though it's more likely that Darwin never knew about the life of Muhammad صلى الله على و سلم.


But there is a contradiction.

Jump two chapters later (chapter 5) he speaks about how the Holy Inquisition brought Spain down after it was great and full of civilisation. But who did the Holy Inquisition take Spain over from? Exactly, the Muslims. So Muslims made Spain great[3] and civilised and here he is talking about our teachings as "strange customs and superstitious" even though it civilised Spain!

Darwin says,

"Who can positively say why the Spanish nation, so dominant at one time, has been distanced in the race? The awakening of the nations of Europe from the dark ages is a still more perplexing problem. At this early period, as Mr Galton[4] has remarked, almost all men of a gentle, nature, those given to meditation or culture of the mind, has no refuge except in the bosom of the Church which demanded celibacy;[5] and this could hardly fail to have had a deteriorating influence on each successive generation. During this same period the Holy Inquisition selected with extreme care the freest and boldest men in order to burn or imprison them. In Spain alone some of the best men - those who doubted and questioned, and without there can be no progress - were eliminated during three centuries at the rate of a thousand a year. The evil which the Catholic Church has thus effected, though no doubt counterbalanced to a certain, perhaps large extent in other ways, is incalculable; nevertheless, Europe has progressed at an unparalleled rate" (137 - italics are mine) 

Let me break it down since it's a mouthful. 

So first Spain was a great nation, so dominant (i.e. so civilised according to context) but then it started to be impotent. Why? Because of the Holy Inquisition. The question is what is the Holy Inquisition? The Holy Inquisition were Catholics who took control of Spain and would kill, burn, torture, you name it, anyone who doubted Catholicism, even if you were from another sect of Christianity! They would send their men to people who they thought were not practising Catholicism their way. They would knock on the door and ask if you are so and so, then, after so and so comes, they would say "the Holy Office (i.e. the Church) summons you" and as a good Catholic you would go to the Holy Office. They would bring you to a room and sit you down, sometimes for hours, asking you question after question (hence the name "Holy Inquisition") about your life, age, family etc. Then they would ask you about the un-Catholic practice you were accused of doing, for example, not eating pork. You would say something like "I don't like pork" but they wouldn't see it like that. They then would strip you semi naked, torture you and then say that they want to "save your soul" because they accused you of, for example, being Jewish (since Jews don't eat pork) and would keep on torturing you until you 'confess' or until they were happy that you have been tortured enough. There is a movie about this called Goya's Ghost, watch it and you'll see the meaning of the Holy Inquisition. But this is what Darwin was talking about. Due to this evil practice, the Catholics killed all the best men who doubted Catholicism (and without doubt there is no progress) and thus brought the civilised Spain to uncivilised Spain but nevertheless Europe in general evolved rapidly. 

I hope this made sense to you. So what is Darwin saying? Though perhaps he himself didn't realise, is that Muslims civilised Spain (due to our teachings) but there he is saying how Niqab is superstitious and of course our Prophet having weak powers of reasoning. So were Muslims civilised (thus great power of reasoning) or not civilised (then fair enough, no contradiction)? Darwin didn't see the contradiction. 

There is more but this is extra. He also speaks about the superstitious belief of "...a Hindoo who breaks his caste..." (75) 

I would agree with Darwin that it is definitely superstitious and it is a racist caste system (as far as I have heard, but if there is more to this "caste system" then please do tell me). But what is ironic is that Darwin made his own caste system based on biological 'scientific' superstitious belief with no evidence whatsoever. 

Of course the above shows that you can be 'civilised' and have an 'inferior mind' - contrary to Darwin's vision of human evolution.

Summary

Charles Darwin certainly was no historian and what he knew about history is what was viral in the society. Holy Inquisition ended in the 19th century, so it would've been news at the time.

Darwin's view of man's history was wrong. If he was right that people with inferior mind can't civilise yet then Spain couldn't have been civlised, but it was. This is where he contradicted himself. And his views on the Niqab is an example of historical prejudice.

و الله اعلم

(Note: People ask (due to my "Was Darwin Racist?" article) why is evolution racist, even if Darwin was? The answer is that evolution requires three things in order for it to work: (1) hereditary (2) different reproduction and (3) variation. The "variation" is the important one. Variation according to natural selection (i.e. evolution) means different success in life. Some live, some die. As we have seen before we know who lives and who needs to die. It's a requirement of natural selection in order for it to work, without it, it can't work. That is why Darwin repeated these three requirements right at the start in Descent by saying whether man differs even if so slightly (variation),

"He who wishes to decide whether man is modified descendant of some pre-existing form, would probably first enquire whether man varies, however slightly..." (9)

And whether we pass hereditary (hereditary + reproduction),

"The enquirer would next come to the important point, whether man tends to increase at so rapid a rate, as to lead to occasional severe struggles for existence, and consequently to beneficial variations... being preserved, and injurious ones eliminated" (9)

If we deny variation, then natural selection didn't create humans (it didn't anyway) and there's no need to believe that we are heading anywhere like those trans-humanist believe in.)

Notes


1. Charles Darwin, Darwin: The Descent of Man, Wordsworth Classics of World Literature.


2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammedan


3. For more information on Muslim Spain, read S. E. Al-Djazairi, 2005, The Hidden Debt to Islamic Civilisation, Bayt Al-Hikma Press.


4. He is the cousin of Darwin and the father of Eugenics. His book Hereditary Genius affected the thinking of Darwin. 



5. As far as I know it was Augustine of Hippo who introduced this teaching, a bid'ah.

Wednesday, 5 October 2016

Was Darwin Racist?

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله

Georges Cuvier (1769-1832) is known today as the father of palaeontology. Cuvier is not known for racism. When Cuvier had a black servant (captured at age 7 from Guinea) he praised him and he liked him. But something happened during his life, which is unknown until today and he became very racist, giving racism a foundation in biology. People before him like Edward Long (1734-1813), who promoted slavery had similar ideas, Samuel Thomas Soemmering (1755-1830), who promoted that the moor (blacks) have thick nerves, therefore less brain matter which according to him proved that the blacks were inferior in mental faculty, Charles White (1728-1813), who lived in Manchester and was influenced by the work(s) of Long, claimed that Africans had similar features as apes and somehow that because Africans had different lice on their head he believed that it shows that Africans are different from the white. But he did disagree with slavery and believed they had souls. At least he agreed with that.

Cuvier was examining a woman that was strange to him and people in general. She was captured from Africa and she was from the Hottentot tribe. They, with her permission (surprisingly), put her in a cage and exhibited her in London and then sent back to Paris and Cuvier got permission to examine her. She became known as the Hottentot Venus[1]. People went all sensational over her because she had a large posterior. After Cuvier examined her, she later on died. But Cuvier remembers her as,

"She had a way of pouting her lips exactly like what we have observed in the orangutan. Her movements had something abrupt and fantastical about them, reminding one of those of the ape. Her lips were monstrously large. Her ear was like that of many apes, being small, the tragus weak, and for external border almost obliterated behind. These are animal characteristics. I have never seen a human head more like an ape than that of this women."[2]

He carries on describing her as brutal, disgusting and reminding him of a monkey tribe and female Mandrills (a colourful ape).[3]

But the prejudice against Hottentot tribe (and Africans in general) carried on and was used by Charles Darwin (1809-1882) himself who claimed that Africans, South Americans, Native Americans and Australians were all evidence of his theory of evolution.

Charles Darwin in his Descent of Man[4], in his Introduction said,

"The conclusion that man co-descendant with other species of some ancient, lower, and extinct form, is not in any degree new. Lamarck long ago came to this conclusion, which has lately been maintained by several eminent naturalists and philosophers; for instance by Wallace, Huxley, Lyell, Vogt, Lubbock, Buchner, Rolle, &c. and especially by Hackel"[5]

I want to just give the full name and what they said just so that you know what sort of people Darwin is citing. Alfred Russel Wallace, Thomas Henry Huxley, Charles Lyell, Carl Vogt, John Lubbock, Ludwig Buchner, Friedrich Rolle and Ernst Haeckel.

A very quick understanding of who they are, I shall just quote their words and let you decide who you think they are (but I will not quote Alfred R. Wallace, Charles Lyell, Ludwig Buchner and Friedrich Rolle because I don't know them much).

"It may be quite true that some negroes are better than some white men; but no rational man, cognisant of the facts, believes that the average negro is the equal, still less the superior, of the average white man. And if this be true, it is simply incredible that, when all his disabilities are removed, and our prognathous relative has a fair field and no favour, as well as no oppressor, he will be able to compete successfully with his bigger-brained and smaller-jawed rival, in a contest on by thoughts and not by bites" - Thomas Henry Huxley [6]

"In the brain of the Negro, the central gyri are like those of a foetus of seven months, the second are still less marked. By it's rounded apex and less developed posterior lobe, the Negro brain resembles that of our children, and by the protuberance of the partial lobes, that of our females. The shape of the brain, the volume of the vermis and of pineal gland, assign to the Negro brain is a place by the side of that of the white child" - Carl Vogt [7]

"Savages may be likened to children, and the comparison is not only correct but also highly instructive. Many naturalist consider that the early condition of the individual [i.e. child] indicates that of the race... So also it is in the case of man; the life of each individual is an epitome of the history of the race, and the gradual development of the child illustrates that of species. Hence the importance of the similarity between savages and children. Savages, like children, have no steadiness of purpose" - John Lubbock (known as Lord Avebury) [8]

"But the apes can grasp with the hind-foot as well as the fore, and so were regarded as quadrumanous. However, the inability to grasp that we find in the foot of civilised man is a consequence of the habit of clothing it with tight coverings for thousands of years. Many of the bare-footed lower races of men, especially among the negroes, use the foot very freely in the same way as the hand. As a result of early habit and continued practice, they can grasp with the foot (in climbing trees, for instances) just as well as with the hand" - Ernst Haeckel [9]

What is common between them all? You're right, they are all racist. They and other racists were used in Darwin's Descent. If Darwin was not a racist he would not have quoted them or would have at least talked against them but he didn't. In fact he agreed with them. Darwin, in the beginning of his life, was not racist and his grandfather in law, Josiah Wedgewood (1730-1795) and his grandfather, Erasmus Darwin (1731-1802) were both against slavery.[10] And surely Darwin was clearly affected by it. His racist ideas were shown very clearly in his Descent. The Origin of Species is important but Darwin did not talk about man and since he didn't talk about man then I can't quote it to show his racism. He does mention that some races are favoured over the other which is what natural selection means (and survival of the fittest) but he didn't enumerate which race is favourable but when those that I quoted above read the Origin, they immediately pointed their fingers at the blacks. Darwin used their work to construct his Descent. So basically Darwin wrote the Origin, the racists used it to construct conclusions and these conclusions were used by Darwin in Descent. A nice circle. [11]

In Descent Darwin elaborated his views as he himself said "This work... [is] the conclusions at which I arrived after drawing up a rough draft, appeared to me interesting, I thought that they might interest others"[12], so no one can say that Darwin was showing what society at the time believed rather it's Darwin beliefs.[13] Darwin begins asking if man descended from some lower form then we expect bodily differences and mental faculty differences (so straight from the start Darwin already believes that different races got different level of intelligence),

"He who wishes to decide whether man is the modified descendant of some pre-existing form, would probably first enquire whether man varies, however slight, in bodily structure and in mental faculty..." (9)

Then he asks rhetorical questions about whether man reproduces a lot and rapid which would naturally lead to "beneficial" and "injurious" traits - the beneficial preserved and injurious eliminated,

"The enquirer would next come to the important point, whether man tends to increase at so rapid a rate, as to led to occasional severe struggles for existence, and consequently to beneficial variations, whether in body or mind, being preserved, and injurious ones eliminated."(9-10)

Darwin answers all these rhetorical questions in the affirmative because it is obvious,

"We shall see that all these questions, as indeed is obvious in respect to most of them, must be answered in the affirmative..." (10, italics are mine and all quotes quoted with italics are mine)

Then Darwin started to list all the alleged evidence to support his claim that there are different levels of superiority between the races of man. I will not mention every single one of them since there are many but a few will be pretty enough. It's also important to understand that his views mirror his evolutionary thinking. Meaning that what Darwin thought is evolution since he was the one who created the idea of unguided evolution and understood it well.

Darwin talked about how fissures and folds (the organisation of the brain) in the brain differs between humans and orangutans because if they were the same then the orangutan would have same mental powers (i.e. intelligence) as humans, which means that if you don't have the same mental power as the white man then the organisation of your brain is different,

"The brain, the most important of all the organs, follows the same law, as shewn by Huxley and other anatomists. Bischoff, who is a hostile witness, admits that every chief fissure and fold in the brain if has its analogy in that of the orang; but he adds that at no period of development do their brains perfectly agree; nor could this be expected, for otherwise their mental powers would have been the same" (10)

So the logic is clear, the organisation of the brain mirrors intelligence and Darwin was right. Darwin believed that the size of the head mirrors intelligence, but can't be accurately be measured by cubic centimetre,

"No one, I presume, doubts that the large size of the brain in man, relatively to his body, in comparison with that of gorilla or orang, is closely connected with his higher mental powers... On the other hand, no one supposes that the intellect of any two animals or of any two men can accurately gauged by the cubic contents of their skulls." (108)

Then Darwin carries on the next paragraph to quote the famous neurologist Paul Broca (and one other) in order to support his hypothesis that the savages had smaller heads sizes compared to those of civilised people,


This table[14] was used by Darwin to derive his numbers 1484 (number 29) and 
1426 (number 23, even though it clearly says 1425, perhaps Darwin misread?). 

"Dr J. Barnard Davis has proved by many careful measurements, that the mean internal capacity of the skull in Europeans is 92.3 cubic inches; in Americans 87.5; in Asiatics 87.1; and in Australians only 81.9 inches. Professor Broca found that skulls from the graves in Paris of the nineteenth century, were larger than those from vaults of the twelth century, in proportion of 1484 to 1426; and Prichard is persuaded that the present inhabitants of Britain have 'much more capacious brain-cases than the ancient inhabitants" (108)

However Darwin admits that Neanderthal (another type of human, stocky and well built) have larger head size which is an anomaly but Darwin didn't say much apart from "Nevertheless it must be admitted that some skulls of very high antiquity, such as the famous one of Neanderthal, are well developed and capacious." (108) That is the only time he talks about Neanderthal in his Descent. It doesn't mean he doubted the gradual head size theory rather he left it for future inquiry, perhaps he wished that it wasn't true? Just like the Cambrian fossils, it was and it is a clear anomaly but he had faith that the future shall solve it (but it didn't). The table above of course "proves" that the Australians and Hottentot have small heads, 1228-1230cc, compared to the English, 1572-95cc. I'm sure Darwin was chuffed with himself. Savage to civilisation. (The table missed the Arabs!)

Now that you've seen the evidence that Darwin clearly believed that somehow intelligence and head size mirrors each other and that the reason why certain humans are dumber is due to their lack of evolution. So we can make a general law that Darwin believed in - small head = inferior brain organisation = generally black. Whilst big head = superior brain size = white.

Here is a small list of Darwin's racism against the "savage" races:

1. Darwin claims that birds have evolved better "sense of beauty" compared to the savages,

"Judging from the hideous ornaments and the equally hideous music admired by most savages, it might be urged that their aesthetic faculty was not so highly developed as in certain animals, for instance, in birds" (49)

2. Darwin claims that there are missing links in human evolution but because the savage races exists, the "gap" between ape-like and the whites is small. However, when the whites exterminates the savages, and they will by the number of centuries, the "gap" will become wider than before,

"But all these breaks depend merely on the number of related forms which have become extinct. At some future period, not very distant as measured by centuries, the civilised races of man will almost certainly exterminate and replace throughout the world the savage races... The break will then be rendered wider..." (155)

In other words, the savage races of today are like missing links and their disappearance will make the gap bigger than ever. 

3. Darwin claims that the black people still have inferior foot, similar but not exactly of apes,

"To gain this great advantage [bipedalism], the feet have become rendered flat, and the great toe peculiarly modified, though this has entailed the loss of the power of prehension [grasping with the toe like those of apes].  It accords with the principle of the division of physiological labour, prevailing throughout the animal kingdom, that as the hands became perfected for prehension, the feet should have become perfected for support and locomotion. With some savages, however, the foot has not altogether lost its prehensile power, as shewn by their manner of climbing trees, and of using them in other ways" (106)

So some savages still have ape-like foot because of the "manner" of climbing trees. Darwin never actually cites an example of that sentence, but what does it mean "manner of climbing trees"? Even I climb trees but I am sure I have a foot like any other white person. But whatever Darwin meant it is clear he's saying that some savages have still not evolved.

4. Darwin claims that America became "great" after the people from all over Europe colonised America ten or twelve generations ago, 

"The remarkable success of the English as colonists, over other European nations, which is well illustrated by comparing the progress of the Canadians of English and French extraction, has been ascribed to their "daring and persistent energy"; but who can say how the English gained their energy? There is apparently much truth in the belief that the wonderful progress of the United States, as well as the character of the people, are the results of natural selection; for the more energetic, restless, and courageous men from all parts of Europe have emigrated during the last ten or twelve generations to that great country, and have there succeeded best." (137)

Darwin carries on,

"Looking to the distant future, I do not think that the Rev. Mr. Zincke takes an exaggerated view when he says: "All other series of events--as that which resulted in the culture of mind in Greece, and that which resulted in the empire of Rome--only appear to have purpose and value when viewed in connection with, or rather as subsidiary to...the great stream of Anglo- Saxon emigration to the west." (137)

And carries on,

"Obscure as is the problem of the advance of civilisation, we can at least see that a nation which produced during a lengthened period the greatest number of highly intellectual, energetic, brave, patriotic, and benevolent men, would generally prevail over less favoured nations." (137-138)

It should be quite obvious that what happened "ten or twelve generations" ago in America was the slaughter of the native Americans and Darwin himself says that it is legitimate to say "Never, never trust an Indian" (due to their barbaric behaviour) (72). So the slaughter of unevolved people by evolved people brought greatness to the land (ultimately due to natural selection). Not only that, the reason why Greece was superior was due to the "great stream of Anglo-Saxon" (i.e. white) people. Ironically the belief that evolved people causes land in which unevolved people live become great was in fact a belief Hitler shared. Hitler says in Mein Kampf,

"Thus, for the formation of higher cultures the existence of lower human types was one of the most essential preconditions, since they alone were able to compensate for the lack of technical aids without which a higher development is not conceivable... Hence it is no accident that the first cultures arose in places where the Aryan, in his encounters with lower peoples, subjugated them and bent them to his will."[15]

And Hitler claims that the Aryans,

"...were in reality the originators of all the great cultures" - he mentions the civilisation of Egypt, Persia and Greece [16]

So Greece, Egypt and Persia and basically all Europe owe their greatness to the Aryans, without which there is no civilisation (because the savages can't civilise - as Darwin claims because the savage have "...weak power of self command" (74) (even though the context was about morality).

It's not so surprising that Darwin and Hitler had similar thoughts since both of them were pretty much exposed to similar ideas & both were evolutionists. 

4. Darwin claims that the reasons why savages have "low morality... are,

firstly, the confinement of sympathy to the same tribe. Secondly, insufficient powers of reasoning, so that the bearing of many virtues, especially of the self-regarding virtues, on the general welfare of the tribe is not recognised... And thirdly, weak power of self-command; for this power has not been strengthened through long-continued, perhaps inherited, habit, instruction and religion" (74)

Thanks to religion (here Darwin means the belief of unseen spirits), the savage race remained savage. Darwin claims that the reason why savages have religion (belief in unseen spirits) in the first place is due to their "poorly developed" reasoning. (52) Which is why religion is more common "with the less civilised races." (50) He even claims that the belief in unseen spirits is like a dog believing that someone is moving the parasol when it's just the breeze doing so. (51) Darwin also claims there is no evidence for the belief that the belief of an Omnipotent God is innate in people (i.e. there's no such thing as Fitrah as the Prophet Muhammad صلى الله على و سلم told us) (50).

Since we have a pretty good understanding of how Darwin perceived the savages; as morally stupid, mentally degraded, as dogs, ape-like foot, small heads and simply inferior down the evolutionary ladder, it's important what, those who love Darwin, say about Darwin's clear cut racism.

I went on Youtube to see what evolutionist say about Darwin's racism. I clicked on the video uploaded by "TheAtheistExperience" and the questioner (Joel, from New York) asks about Darwin's racism and just to summarise the 7 min video, the answer was "so what if Darwin was racist?". That was the answer. It's important to understand how idiotic such an answer is, what do you mean "so what if Darwin is/was racist?"  I give them credit that they admit that Darwin was racist since many just will not say so but ending it with "so what if Darwin is racist?" is the most horrible thing I've heard.

The claim that Darwin's evolutionary racism does not mirror evolution today is wrong. Just because "scientists" of today deny the racist implications does not mean evolution is not racist. Evolution requires differences in mental faculty and bodily structure - without which evolution doesn't work. Today racism is abhorred and that is the reason why "scientist" deny the racism in evolution. If natural selection integrated into animals the drive force of supplanting the weaker by: extermination, depriving of food or other means, which led to the evolution of higher animals, [17] then divorcing racism from evolution is evidence against evolution from a moral perspective. Individual thoughts must not determine the belief system. The belief system should determine itself or the author of the belief. Which simply means that if the belief itself is racist then all those who follow it, with it's racist belief, are right but if some don't then they are wrong and doubting their very own belief. Darwin's belief is racist and that is enough evidence that evolution is wrong since racism is morally & objectively wrong.

Others claim that because Darwin believed in monogenism (all humans came from one ape-like creature) that proves Darwin isn't racist. I don't see how that alone makes someone not racist, Darwin was still racist with the monogenism belief.

Summarising

What I'm trying to say is something quite simple:

1. Charles Darwin was clearly influenced by racism and is racist and will remain racist despite what others want to say.

2. Charles Darwin read a lot of racist work. If he was not racist he then at least would not have quoted it in his work or he might do but disagree like he did with the belief of polygenism - the belief that difference races of man, like European, African, Asian and American came from different ape-like creatures. However as James MacGregor Allan said back in 1869 "The Darwinist may be monogenist or polygenist" because its "consistent with Darwinism to believe in unity or plurality."[18]

3. The people at the time of Darwin knew the racist implications of the theory and advocated it. For example, Darwin cites William Rathbone Greg in his Descent. I looked at Darwin's reference and decided to look for that periodical which Darwin referenced. The periodical is entitled 'On the failure of 'natural selection' in the case of man'. And right from the start, Greg summarises the whole theory of evolution in a paragraph, he says,

"Everyone now is familiar with the Darwinian theory of the origin of species, at least in its main principles and outlines: and nearly all men qualified to form an opinion are convinced of it substantial truth. That theory explains how races of animals vary as ages roll on, so as to adapt themselves to the changing external conditions which those ages bring about. At every given moment, in every given spot on the earth's surface, a 'struggle of existence' is going on among all the forms of organic life, animal and vegetable, then and there alive; a struggle in which, as there is not room for all, the weaker and less adapted succumb, while the stronger and better adapted survive and multiply. As surrounding circumstances, climatic or geological, vary and are modified, corresponding variations (such as are always incidentally appearing among the offspring of all creatures) in the inhabitants of each district crop up, increases, spread and become permanent. The creatures that are most in harmony with surrounding circumstances have a manifest daily and hourly advantage over those which are less in harmony; live when they die; flourish when they fade; endure through what kills others; can find food, catch prey, escape enemies, when their feebler, slower, blinder brethren, are starved and slain. Thus the most perfect specimens of each race and tribe, the strongest, the swiftest, the healthiest, the most courageous-those fullest of vitality-live longest, feed best, overcome their competitors in the choice of mates; and, in virtue of these advantages, become-as it is desirable they should be-the originator of the future race. The poorer, specimens, the sick, the faulty, the weak, are slain or drop out of existence; are distanced in the chase, are beaten in the fight, can find no females to match with them; and the species is propagated and continued mainly. increasingly, if not exclusively, from its finest and most selected individuals-in a word, it's elite." [19]

I am not claiming that Darwin invented racism, obviously he did not, but rather Darwin justified racism because "Natural selection was now predicated on the weaker being extinguished. Individuals, races even, had to perish for progress to occur. Thus it was, that 'Wherever the European has trod, death seems to pursue the aboriginal'. Europeans were the agents of Evolution. Prichard's warning about aboriginal slaughter was intended to alert the nation, but Darwin was already naturalizing the cause and rationalizing the outcome." [20] 

If Darwin was not racist then Darwin would have never written Origin of Species or the Descent of Man. 

I end with this quote,

"...but for him [Darwin] the 'progress' was writ on a grander canvas - the benefit was to the entire species. Extermination was an axiom of nature - 'strictly applicable to the universe', as he said. Nature herself moved forward, crushing skulls underfoot. 'The varieties of man seem to act on each other; in the same way as different species of animals - the stronger always extirpating the weaker', he wrote in his Journal" [21]

Actually I'll end with this because, you see, Darwin summarised his theory in couple of words,

"On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of favoured races in the struggle for life"

If preservation of "favoured" races is not racist then perhaps you are racist.

الله المستعان و الله اعلم

(Note: I wrote this article swiftly, perhaps, God willing, I will type a more clear and detailed article on the racism of Darwin's faith (since there is much more to explain than just what I showed above). This article is just to give a quick response to a video uploaded by LDM (London Dawah Movement). The video shows Subboor talking to a black man at a stall called London Black Atheist. Then after talking for a minute about how black people are (majority of them) religious, Subboor talks about polygenists claiming that because blacks and whites have different origins therefore one is evolved more than the other and that's why blacks would believe in some religion rather than atheism. So that man claims that it wasn't Darwin's view and to one extent he's right, Darwin clearly was a monogenist but he still believed that blacks have inferior brain organisation (as I mentioned above) and that is why blacks make religion and why religion is common among savages. The video goes on showing how that man is trying his best to show that all these racism that evolutionists created were irrelevant to Darwin but I beg to differ, Darwin is at the heart of it all and that man is trying to defend the racist Darwin. I feel sorry for the parents that gave birth to you, though most likely you will never read this)

Notes and references

1. A little history of Hottentot Venus http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/14/books/review/Elkins.t.html?_r=0

2. Georges Cuvier, 1817, Etudes sur l'ibis es Memoire sur la Venus hottentotte. You can find the quote also in Stephen Jay Gould, 2007, The Richness of Life, Vintage, page 497 and Gustav Jahoda, 1999, Images of Savages, Routledge, page 79.

3. Images of Savages, page 79.

4. Charles Darwin, Darwin: The Descent of Man, Wordsworth Classics of World Literature.

5. Ibid, page 4-5.

6. Thomas H. Huxley, Collected Essays, Vol III, Chapter, Emancipation-Black and White, page 66-67.

7. Carl Vogt, 1864, Lectures on Man, page 183.

8. I added the word "child" just for explanation. Sir John Lubbock, 1913 (7th edition. But first edition printed in 1863) Prehistoric Times, Williams and Norgate, page 562-563.

9. Ernst Haeckel, 1911 (first edition 1876 in German language), The Evolution of Man 2nd volume, chapter "Our ape ancestors." (I used the Kindle app and there is no page number).

10. A nice history about them in Adrian Desmond and James Moore, 2009, Darwin's Sacred Cause: Race, slavery and the quest for human origins, Penguin, pages 1-26. But I firmly disagree with the conclusion of the book.

11. Adrian Desmond, James Moore and Janet Browne, 2007, Charles Darwin, Very Interesting People, page 83

12. ref 4, page 4. (The 'I' being italic was done by me for emphasis)

13. Even though no one said such thing but someone out there will surely think this way.

14. Carl Vogt, 1864, Lectures on Man, page 88 and this reference was cited in Charles Darwin, Darwin: The Descent of Man, Wordsworth Classics of World Literature, page 121, ref 71

15. Cited in Richard Weikart, 2009, Hitler's Ethic: The Nazi pursuit of evolutionary ethics, Palgrave Macmillan, page 76.  

16. Ibid, page 77.

17. Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species, Wordsworth Classics of World Literature, page 369

18. James MacGregor Allan, 1869, The Anthropological Review, Vol 7, No. 25 (Apr., 1869), page 178

19. William Rathbone Greg, September 1868, Fraser's Magazine, On the Failure of 'Natural Selection' in the Case of Man, page 353-354

20. Adrian Desmond and James Moore, 2009, Darwin's Sacred Cause: Race, slavery and the quest for human origins, Penguin, page 151

21. Ibid